Jump to content

A Call to Roleplay


Cam

Recommended Posts

Posted

+1 I would have to agree on this. It sucked at the time trying to run either the restaurant or gun store and having an open floodgate of people fucking around more than actual people larping, and usually in turn with them minging, their stupid ass name follows suit. I feel if there was more of a crackdown on ridiculous names it might make people lean towards a more normal name rather than something stupid and seen as a throwaway char and it could make them lean towards wanting to actually rp. Yea it’s not gonna stop people from minging or making a char for causing a hard time for others completely, but it might help lessen the amount of people immediately going to cause problems with others 

  • Like 2
Posted
50 minutes ago, Cam said:

I wasn’t aware of anyone being afraid to engage in roleplay out of fear of being blacklisted. In my opinion, I would see NOT roleplaying would get them blacklisted from some factions, but I also can see how some people are hesitant to roleplay to full potential, especially first starting out.
 

I know for myself and some others, we may not necessarily blacklist someone for bad roleplay, but we will if they are just straight up being a minge. I don’t think all roleplay, even if silly, is bad. Silly people exist in the real world, so having quirks and stuff is fine.

Some of the best roleplay comes from people who give their characters silly characteristics because it encourages roleplay and focuses characters out of being self-inserts. When they repeat things two times, maybe they have a fondness for steak that makes them go a bit silly sometimes but otherwise be normal, maybe they have a secret hatred for something and when they see it they get enraged.

Can you elaborate on the fear of roleplay? Like what kind of roleplay are people afraid of? 

I’m not talking about people being afraid to give their characters silly personalities or quirks. I’m talking about people being hesitant to create meaningful conflict because of the consequences that might follow.

When the majority of powerful factions are allied with one another, it leaves very little room for anyone to challenge the status quo without risking being blacklisted, embargoed, or isolated.

And that’s part of the bigger problem. There’s only so much RP you can get out of everyone being friendly with one another. The constant “let’s go eat here,” gabagool this, gabagool that, and sitting around having the same conversations eventually gets repetitive. At some point, people run out of things to actually roleplay and those interactions turn into OOC conversations disguised as IC ones.

Conflict creates stories. Rivalries, betrayals, internal power struggles, and political maneuvering give characters something to react to and factions something to work toward. Ironically, when someone actually introduces that kind of drama, they’re often criticized for it. Yet a struggling faction facing a coup or an outsider stirring up trouble is arguably some of the most lore-accurate mafia RP you could have.

You can’t expect an interesting criminal underworld when everyone is politically aligned, nobody wants to upset anyone, and the safest way to survive is to be everyone’s friend. At that point, you’re not really roleplaying organized crime. You’re roleplaying a social club with Italian accents.

  • Like 2
  • Dumb 1
  • Agree 1
Posted
11 hours ago, Cam said:

image.png.9a099922de259a9fa5189ba4171e4130.png

 

ooc name btw

  • Funny 1
Posted
12 hours ago, vdot.co said:

Put Ravioli on that list

Bro thats my name

  • Funny 2
Posted
2 hours ago, vdot.co said:

ooc name btw

It’s an actual surname with historical documentation + they provided an entire backstory on how their family came to be established in NY, and the history of the name.

More RP then the name I first used from an online Italian name generator.

  • Funny 2
Posted (edited)
10 hours ago, Geo_Zeus said:

Most people on the server got too much of an ego for any good-faith RP to take place. When every decision or outcome gets appealed to the moon and back, the players use cheats, metagame, alt etc. to get the upper hand and having staff members in your faction is considered a good thing instead of a neutral thing you can forget about RP. There's alot of insecure chuds that don't really got anything going on in their lives and jerk themselves off over the power and influence they have in this videogame and as long as nobody does anything about that, this is exactly how it's gonna be.

“Too much ego for good faith rp” and its someone refusing to interact with someone or take them seriously because they call themselves “the don clown”.

If your style of rp is overtly retarded and unserious, then obviously you are going to be shunned from the circles of people who take the game more seriously. Saying “Oh well you would have to fix metagame before I take the server seriously” is such an insanely bad take. 

If you get blacklisted from a faction, then deal with it like a normal person and wait it out or move to a different faction. You shouldn’t go around minging and flinging cars into the air because you caught a blacklist from an alliance/faction. The people who would use that reason to excuse their behavior, are the people who never took the server seriously in the first place.

Obviously this is a game, and nobody should be acting like this is their real life, but you can’t act like a belligerent ape and expect people to accept you with open arms into their circles.

3 hours ago, Fritz said:

People are afraid of a lot of types of RP in connection from being blacklisted from different parts of the server

Snitching: Oh you snitched on 2 of my allies while you were in their factions? Come over to my faction too so you can do the same!

Mugging: You mugged 3 members of my faction for ooc beef? Yeah let me put you in my faction with access to all of the places we do our secret illegal activity so that you can rob us more efficiently. No, kill yourself.

Being a degenerate freak: You roleplayed as someone who went up to chicks and sniffed their panties? Yeah ofc you can come into my faction as well! No, kill yourself.

Going undercover: You lied to our ally for the past 2 months both IC and in OOC vcs to fuck them over as much as possible? Yeah it seems like you can be trusted to main my faction this go around! No, kill yourself.

Blacklisting someone for being s lawyer or DA is retarded though, ill agree on that.

Edited by DopeAsRoe
  • Like 5
  • Helpful & Informative 1
Posted

Another thing is that if a staff member cant determine that someone has a minge/gag name, then they are obviously too retarded, young, or foreign to be a staff member in the first place.

  • Like 4
  • Helpful & Informative 1
Posted

The people who get mad when they get kicked out of a nice restaurant for wearing a clown mask or wizard outfit are like the people you see chimping out irl for getting kicked out of popeyes because they dont accept EBT

  • Like 2
  • Funny 3
Posted

Fuck you clown niggas, fuck you chicken head niggas #wop4life

  • Like 2
  • Funny 2
Posted
5 minutes ago, Jennay said:

Fuck you clown niggas, fuck you chicken head niggas #wop4life

I have no idea how this is allowed

  • Funny 1
Posted
5 hours ago, DooDOOShid said:

 

When the majority of powerful factions are allied with one another, it leaves very little room for anyone to challenge the status quo without risking being blacklisted, embargoed, or isolated.

 

You can’t expect an interesting criminal underworld when everyone is politically aligned, nobody wants to upset anyone, and the safest way to survive is to be everyone’s friend. At that point, you’re not really roleplaying organized crime. You’re roleplaying a social club with Italian accents.

Need he need to say more? Was threatened to be blacklisted EVERYWHERE if I wanted to join in on the Lucheese vs popov war. WAS blacklisted from Lucheese for a mug I didn't do. MY BLACKLIST WAS REINSTATED because I got into a few shootouts with Lucheese WHILE ON MY POPOV CHAR. If its #bringbackRP then it should also be #keepitic

  • Agree 1
  • Funny 1
Posted

“ I cant roleplay I got blacklisted in this faction 😭” Nigga just join another one and roleplay there, the objective of the server is to roleplay no matter what faction you’re in this isnt just an italian faction thing. Also you’re not getting blacklisted because you’re in a conflict, you’re getting blacklisted because you suck. 

  • Helpful & Informative 2
  • Funny 2
Posted
1 hour ago, Jennay said:

“ I cant roleplay I got blacklisted in this faction 😭” Nigga just join another one and roleplay there, the objective of the server is to roleplay no matter what faction you’re in this isnt just an italian faction thing. Also you’re not getting blacklisted because you’re in a conflict, you’re getting blacklisted because you suck. 

Can't even name a character Mister V. Cappintosh, without u getting your panties in a bunch.

  • Dumb 1
Posted (edited)

I mean roleplay in general needs to be done better all around. Cops do a better job having rp than any crim faction does. Its either over drawn out cringey bullshit. Over exaggerated accents. or just uncesserious retardation going on. Most of the time the people that SHOULD experience rp to stay in a faction are left out because "the mob wouldnt let them do this" video game but okay.

Having "godfather" moments doesnt add to the rp either. 

Theres a lot that could be done. 

Forgot to add +1. staff not enforcing basic server rules because theyre lazy or something is a huge problem

Edited by Trak
  • Dumb 2
  • Disagree 1
Posted
1 hour ago, Trak said:

 Cops do a better job having rp than any crim faction does.

Idk if you are just referring to medal ceremonies or who you are interacting with, but this is just not true. 

I told this story in general yesterday but I'll put it here as well.

The other day I'm in Little Italy when a stove exploded somewhere on the block. Two cops were walking by the pizzeria and immediately drew their shotguns and ran inside asking who did it. Instead of actually investigating what actually happened or asking if anybody was hurt, they come in with shotguns and demand to know who just exploded it. The people at the front desk go "I'm not sure, I don't think that was here." and the two cops just walk out lol.

This is how the majority of cops operate these days, and I feel like I'm not alone in saying that. Cops that actually engage in a scene feel few and far between.

I also want to add that cops are almost the biggest proponent of having retarded/gag names, second only to the citizen faction. 

I just went through the PD discord, here are a few names I found:

-Pepperchini Alfredo
-De'Quavious De'Crawford
-Smally Biggs
-Patrick O'Shaghennesy
-Shadynastys O'Henery
-Damascus Dugumf (Your PD character)

  • Like 2
  • Helpful & Informative 1
  • Agree 1
  • Wine 1
Posted

I refuse to RP.

  • Helpful & Informative 1
  • Funny 4
  • Wine 1
Posted
11 hours ago, DopeAsRoe said:

“Too much ego for good faith rp” and its someone refusing to interact with someone or take them seriously because they call themselves “the don clown”.

Never mentioned anything about peopole not interacting with other people because of ego, blacklisting etc. When I say people have too much of an ego for good faith rp i'm talking about the people that will do everything they can to "win" the altercation, going beyond what the server allows(Megaming, staff abuse, cheats, alts, pk hunting etc).

  • Helpful & Informative 2
Posted
14 hours ago, Trak said:

Cops do a better job having rp than any crim faction does

Cop main here: false

  • Like 3
  • Helpful & Informative 1
  • Funny 1
Posted
On 11/17/2026 at 4:12 PM, DooDOOShid said:

I’m not talking about people being afraid to give their characters silly personalities or quirks. I’m talking about people being hesitant to create meaningful conflict because of the consequences that might follow.

When the majority of powerful factions are allied with one another, it leaves very little room for anyone to challenge the status quo without risking being blacklisted, embargoed, or isolated.

And that’s part of the bigger problem. There’s only so much RP you can get out of everyone being friendly with one another. The constant “let’s go eat here,” gabagool this, gabagool that, and sitting around having the same conversations eventually gets repetitive. At some point, people run out of things to actually roleplay and those interactions turn into OOC conversations disguised as IC ones.

Conflict creates stories. Rivalries, betrayals, internal power struggles, and political maneuvering give characters something to react to and factions something to work toward. Ironically, when someone actually introduces that kind of drama, they’re often criticized for it. Yet a struggling faction facing a coup or an outsider stirring up trouble is arguably some of the most lore-accurate mafia RP you could have.

You can’t expect an interesting criminal underworld when everyone is politically aligned, nobody wants to upset anyone, and the safest way to survive is to be everyone’s friend. At that point, you’re not really roleplaying organized crime. You’re roleplaying a social club with Italian accents.

Screenshot2026-11-18182508.png.5cd472e5dc7c19e20ab23bc0507d1a67.png

  • Helpful & Informative 2
  • Funny 1
Posted
16 hours ago, Trak said:

 Cops do a better job having rp than any crim faction does. Its either over drawn out cringey bullshit. Over exaggerated accents. or just uncesserious retardation going on.

you are smokin straight dick nigga

  • Helpful & Informative 3
Posted (edited)
17 hours ago, DopeAsRoe said:

Idk if you are just referring to medal ceremonies or who you are interacting with, but this is just not true. 

I told this story in general yesterday but I'll put it here as well.

The other day I'm in Little Italy when a stove exploded somewhere on the block. Two cops were walking by the pizzeria and immediately drew their shotguns and ran inside asking who did it. Instead of actually investigating what actually happened or asking if anybody was hurt, they come in with shotguns and demand to know who just exploded it. The people at the front desk go "I'm not sure, I don't think that was here." and the two cops just walk out lol.

This is how the majority of cops operate these days, and I feel like I'm not alone in saying that. Cops that actually engage in a scene feel few and far between.

I also want to add that cops are almost the biggest proponent of having retarded/gag names, second only to the citizen faction. 

I just went through the PD discord, here are a few names I found:

-Pepperchini Alfredo
-De'Quavious De'Crawford
-Smally Biggs
-Patrick O'Shaghennesy
-Shadynastys O'Henery
-Damascus Dugumf (Your PD character)

I said this to another person and I'll just admit it here. I mostly said that to ragebait, to a point. In some areas I think Crim RP is extremely boring and engaging RP is left to Capo+. Otherwise being anythign else is "run shipments and do restaurant RP" and that just gets extremely old and boring. 

There needs to be new engaging moneymakers or ways to have self brought in RP scenarios without risking a political nightmare thats just gonna get you pked from your faction. This is why I previously suggested an NPC extortion RP. Other people said "redo the way checks work" cause theyre actively dogwater. 

Grinding shipments and running businesses and dealing with minges just cant be the only thing for low ranks to do. 

I think most cops on the street are retarded and yes I complain about peoples names. Thats why I am IA, so I can help cut down on the PD minginess or those who destroy rp. 

But yeah I also dont mean that. Like actual investigation, the forensic RP. IA investigations. They all over really engaging rp that is fun to do. 

the rp of chasing people being idiots in cars or harassing people over dumb shit is stupid and shouldnt occur. 

Also I do not think my PD name is dumb. It was meant to sound French Creole. lol which I think it does.

Edit: also I have no idea what medal ceremonies are like I skip every one because I assume theyre just a PD HC circle jerk and everyone else just sits there bored until its over.

Edited by Trak
  • Dumb 1
  • Disagree 1
  • Funny 1
Posted

We are larpie kirk. 

  • Helpful & Informative 1
Posted
37 minutes ago, Trak said:

I said this to another person and I'll just admit it here. I mostly said that to ragebait, to a point. In some areas I think Crim RP is extremely boring and engaging RP is left to Capo+. Otherwise being anythign else is "run shipments and do restaurant RP" and that just gets extremely old and boring. 

There needs to be new engaging moneymakers or ways to have self brought in RP scenarios without risking a political nightmare thats just gonna get you pked from your faction. This is why I previously suggested an NPC extortion RP. Other people said "redo the way checks work" cause theyre actively dogwater. 

Grinding shipments and running businesses and dealing with minges just cant be the only thing for low ranks to do. 

I think the issue is that a lot of rackets require you to be creative, and not a lot of people are thinking outside of the box anymore. We used to have people who did porno mags, comic books, pac3, protection/security, book making, illegal card games, and some other stuff I’m definitely forgetting. Obviously porno mags arent around anymore for obvious reasons but the rest are still pretty viable today. Who would spend money on comic books? I have no fucking idea, but I'm just saying that sometimes you gotta get creative with it.

You have these people who say “the only ways to make money is by selling suits, drugs, or guns", but the issue is that the majority of the people who play now are unimaginative, lazy, or just have the IQ of a chimp. So it’s no wonder that the more rp centered rackets are less common these days. I don't think the lack of rackets is entirely a server issue. I think a lot of people have become so used to the server providing them easy ways to make money that they don't really know how to create their own, or even think to do so. Pendred and canadian can only add so many game mechanics to make money before people have to actually start rping and using a bit of brain power. 

I feel like the majority of the newer player base knows the bare minimum when it comes to the mob or how certain criminal organizations made money on the streets. Maybe it’s cringe or retarded to say that because it is a gmod server but how are you gonna join mafia rp and know nothing about the mafia lol. Its like joining SCPrp with no knowledge of what an SCP is and then wondering why all you do is stand around and shoot d-class. If you don't really understand the subject/genre that you are attempting to rp in, then you're obviously going to be limited in how creative you can get with it or how far it can take you.

I love Takahashi and 14k, I think at their core they are good factions, but I feel like they lack people who understand how those types of organizations actually operated, which (imo) causes them to struggle when it comes to establishing an identity beyond just wearing rice hats or robes. They don't have much distinction in how they operate as criminals or conduct business as opposed to the other factions in the city. I think both factions have massive potential for rp, but how much of that potential can really be reached when most of the people in them know next to nothing about the group they're trying to emulate? I'm not saying you need to be some history chud to join a faction, but having some knowledge of how these groups operated, how they made their money, and what made them different from other crim orgs would go a longer way than most people realize. I know I only used those two factions as an example, but this is something I've noticed across multiple factions, both past and present. It becomes an even bigger issue when the same people with a lack of knowledge, become the faction leader. No offense, but what the fuck does @Akira know about running a Jamaican street gang! 😭

I think the data backs up my claims as well☝️🤓. When you look at Lucchese, arguably the most successful faction right now, you see good internal and external rp, unique rackets you don't really see anywhere else, and a very well structured group of people who understand what the mob is, the history of it, and how it actually operated. I don't think its a coincidence that a faction with a good understanding of the thing they're rping is also one of the most successful factions in the city right now. They have access to the same methods and opportunities that every other faction has, so my question is, at what point is it the fault of the players and not the servers mechanics?

As for the lower ranks thing, I do agree to an extent. Obviously newer players are gonna have a harder time coming up with their own rackets or knowing how to go about pursuing them, but I think a lot of that responsibility falls on the capos, soldiers, or other higher ups in the faction. A huge part of being faction command is teaching guys below you how to make money, how to rp, and helping them develop their own ideas. If all you're doing with your associates is having them run shipments and work in restaurants, then of course they're gonna think that's all there is to do on the server! That only perpetuates the cycle for the next batch of new players, which is partly how I think we got to this point lol.

Now of course I would like to see more rackets or money making mechanics added to the server, but I don't think that doing so is gonna magically make people better at larping. In fact, I think that some people have forgotten that things already in place are supposed to help encourage/facilitate rp in the first place. Remember! Just because a mechanic doesn't exist for something, doesn't always mean you can't rp it :classic_smile:

I know this post may come off like I'm shitting on some people or factions, but I'm really not trying to. I just wanted to give my honest thoughts and opinions on this matter. Much love to the asian and black communities!

TLDR: Ask ai, I spent way too much time typing this bullshit.

If you enjoy my forums posts, please consider +1 or wine reacting to all of my posts and hitting me with a follow!


- DopeAsRoe

  • Like 1

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...