Hello, I'm going to comment on this matter, as I am the other individual involved in the clip.
We were approached by a member of Takahashi-Kai and asked to mug a particular individual. We agreed and subsequently spotted the individual leaving PD grounds. We offered her a ride, which she accepted, and she entered my vehicle.
We then drove to the tunnel parking lot, where Hans immediately exited the vehicle, drew his weapon, and ordered her to put her hands up. She did not comply with this order, ran off into the tunnel area and even went as far as typing something in chat instead of COMPLYING under FearRP. This continued for a considerable amount of time, during which she had ample opportunity to comply. As a result of her continued noncompliance, she was killed.
Regarding the individual claiming that "put your hands up" is not a valid command, that is simply incorrect. I do(n't) mean to come across as arrogant, but I've personally administered over 100 PKs during my time as staff, with only two of them ever being overturned. I believe that gives me a fairly solid understanding of what constitutes a valid roleplay command. Ordering someone to put their hands up is an entirely valid roleplay command. An invalid command, on the other hand, would be something along the lines of "flex your F7 muscle," as that explicitly requires a player to use a specific keybind rather than comply with an instruction given through roleplay. There is a clear distinction between the two, and telling someone to put their hands up does not fall into the latter category.
Under the server rules, this individual became subject to PK when she refused to comply and proceeded to walk away despite both of us having our firearms aimed directly at her. I also repeatedly ordered her to return, which she continued to disregard.
I will attach my own clip to provide further context and demonstrate that the individual was given multiple opportunities to comply.
This PK was valid under the server rules, and I genuinely believe Calink erred in his decision. Should this ban appeal be accepted, I also request that the note issued to me as a result of this same incident be removed.
https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/nH2yWR05Oc52v7L1c?invite=cr-MSxpNDQsNDc2NzAzOTA0
Me attempting to explain to Calink what had happened:
https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/nH2QdxWBA6f__HoVb?invite=cr-MSxTZ1csNDc2NzAzOTA0