Matthew Doyle PK Appeal

[JetFlow]

Name of Character:Matthew Doyle

 

Character ID:203298

 

SteamID:STEAM_0:0:695666011

 

Your Discord ID#:jetflow90

Date of PK: 06/09/2026

Reason for PK: Target Mugging/OOC

Why should you be UNPK'd? What server rule or PK rule was violated?: Target/FailRP I was followed inside to the warehouse by 3 masked individuals and was placed under fear RP. I was confused because the guy did say F7 which in the rules I thought was a OOC term that would invalidate the PK. I Then pulled my weapon and did Kill one of them before I eventually ate the bullet.

 

My main Issue is the individual who did mug me is Punisher who was a former SOS President that left on bad terms. He had not been in city for awhile until late last night were he had a conversation with my Don near townhall flexing that he PK'd a former member of SOS and was asking how he was doing.(Mind you this character is not his original SOS character which died". He then ended the convo with "I'm just going to mug one of your guys later". My don was confused why he would say that since it was a different character with no bad interactions against each other. My Don did in fact call over radio text last night that some guy is trying to mug one of us. I would also like to point out in the clip the two other individuals not wearing the red are 100% mugging chars with 0 RP incentives. I would like these individuals to be looked into. If possible please provide video evidence or photo evidence if PK does not follow the guidelines:https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/nsY7McAQzupJ-gDHc?invite=cr-MSwybUEsNDQyMDk1OTk5

Medal - Record what just happened with the press of a button

 

Edited 44 minutes ago by JetFlow
Wrong date sorry

[TMH]

I can second this I was near town hall last night and did overhear Punisher spewing about his past accomplishes on another char killing SOS. He did indeed say he was going to mug one of us, which i thought was kinda petty for 0 escalations.

Brightside he is a bottom shotta and did indeed get dropped.

Edited 49 minutes ago by TMH

[Bullets]

these niggas are mass mugging lol

[TMH]

1 minute ago, Bullets said:

these niggas are mass mugging lol

On god I heard they hit hella people last night and also another guy just before this one.

[Drakarus]

10 minutes ago, JetFlow said:

Name of Character:Matthew Doyle

 

Character ID:203298

 

SteamID:STEAM_0:0:695666011

 

Your Discord ID#:jetflow90

Date of PK: 05/09/2026

Reason for PK: Target Mugging/OOC

Why should you be UNPK'd? What server rule or PK rule was violated?: Target/FailRP I was followed inside to the warehouse by 3 masked individuals and was placed under fear RP. I was confused because the guy did say F7 which in the rules I thought was a OOC term that would invalidate the PK. I Then pulled my weapon and did Kill one of them before I eventually ate the bullet.

 

My main Issue is the individual who did mug me is Punisher who was a former SOS President that left on bad terms. He had not been in city for awhile until late last night were he had a conversation with my Don near townhall flexing that he PK'd a former member of SOS and was asking how he was doing.(Mind you this character is not his original SOS character which died". He then ended the convo with "I'm just going to mug one of your guys later". My don was confused why he would say that since it was a different character with no bad interactions against each other. My Don did in fact call over radio text last night that some guy is trying to mug one of us. I would also like to point out in the clip the two other individuals not wearing the red are 100% mugging chars with 0 RP incentives. I would like these individuals to be looked into. If possible please provide video evidence or photo evidence if PK does not follow the guidelines:https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/nsY7McAQzupJ-gDHc?invite=cr-MSwybUEsNDQyMDk1OTk5

Medal - Record what just happened with the press of a button

 

mugging char???? with 400k + a ton of suits worth more than u + a bank filled with lsd barrels = another 400k and tons of guns, and its my main char lol. you got cooked, you werent complying with the hands up which is because SOS has a rule you cant get mugged with your clothes on and they cant get taken otherwise they gon kill you. I had to help teach you how to put ur hands up but u still werent complying at that point u pulled ur gun and died

[TMH]

3 minutes ago, Drakarus said:

mugging char???? with 400k + a ton of suits worth more than u + a bank filled with lsd barrels = another 400k and tons of guns, and its my main char lol. you got cooked, you werent complying with the hands up which is because SOS has a rule you cant get mugged with your clothes on and they cant get taken otherwise they gon kill you. I had to help teach you how to put ur hands up but u still werent complying at that point u pulled ur gun and died

How do you know that rule? are you specifically targeting SOS to get a PK now? It looks like these past 24 hrs you have done some damage to other people huh?

[Bedoo]

23 minutes ago, JetFlow said:

He had not been in city for awhile until late last night were he had a conversation with my Don near townhall flexing that he PK'd a former member of SOS and was asking how he was doing.(Mind you this character is not his original SOS character which died". He then ended the convo with "I'm just going to mug one of your guys later".

 

23 minutes ago, JetFlow said:

My Don did in fact call over radio text last night that some guy is trying to mug one of us.

Hello, Don that was mentioned here.
Can confirm that one of the muggers here randomly approached me last night, this one in particular was a former SoS HC at one point on a different char, I was the one that had him removed from the faction on bad terms. I kept the conversation casual and talked about racket event. At the end he blurted out that he was going to mug a SoS later and I called it in on radio with a brief description of him. I don't have the conversation clipped but logs might show it if looked into.

Seems like blatant targeting from his end considering the bad blood
 

11 minutes ago, Drakarus said:

you werent complying with the hands up which is because SOS has a rule you cant get mugged with your clothes on and they cant get taken otherwise they gon kill you.

Later we did learn that the group in question was mass mugging and it wouldn't surprise me if they are all mugging chars. 

All clips and information has been submitted to UA.

Edited 31 minutes ago by Bedoo

[Gr1mmy]

Hello. Pking Staff Here.

(If you're not involved in this situation please kindly refrain from posting on this thread)

The rule you're referencing does exist however in this context it is not valid i will explain below.

There are other instances where killing someone during a mugging will not result in a PK
- Such as not giving the person reasonable time to react to your demands
- Ordering them to use certain game functions they don't have to comply with or making unreasonable demands (Drop items/cash, hit f7, give me your f3, commit suicide, etc)

This rule is specifically for when they are giving you orders. There is no situation in the server where whilst being mugged and being told to hit F7 Then Refusing to hit F7 and them killing you for refusing to use the game function would fall under a PK.

If you had Ignored their command to click F7 And they shot you. then it would not have been a PK.

In terms of the Targeting Accusation. when staff reach out to you. then you will be expected to provide that proof and this will help with your appeal. if this is indeed a Targeted instance you will most likely be Unpked and the Mugger will not.

You died because you pulled out a gun and fought back whilst being held under FEARRP which can be seen here.

FearRP = Valuing one's life in a realistic manner.

Life Rules.

1. You must value your character’s life. This means that you naturally do not want your character to die. (FearRP) Breaking this can result in a PK at the Staff’s Discretion.

FearRP Rules.

1. While under fearrp it's recommended you oblige by the commands of your captor, if you attempt to escape or pull out a weapon to fight back but are killed that would display a disregard for your own safety, a calculated risk you took which failed, resulting in your PK. (In some circumstances a PK does not apply, view pk rules for more information.) This means it is NOT a rule violation to break fearrp but if you are killed while breaking it there is a possible IC consequence of being PK'ed.

TLDR: If they killed you for refusing it'd be invalid but because you shot them it's a valid death.

Additionally if you had pulled a gun out on safety whilst they were surrounding you. you wouldn't have been under FearRP and would not have had to comply with Any orders or commands issued.

Thank you for your time.

Edited 25 minutes ago by Gr1mmy
Minor Grammar Changes

[Drakarus]

35 minutes ago, TMH said:

How do you know that rule? are you specifically targeting SOS to get a PK now? It looks like these past 24 hrs you have done some damage to other people huh?

SOS? I just found out abt that today cause I was wondering why the fuck he didnt just surrender and someone enlightened me, I wanna find out how IC you guys got info on who killed him tho??? four ppl there, 2 died. also please read the admins response. Put ur gun down and listen

Edited 2 minutes ago by Drakarus

[TMH]

4 minutes ago, Drakarus said:

SOS? I just found out abt that today cause I was wondering why the fuck he didnt just surrender and someone enlightened me, I wanna find out how IC you guys got info on who killed him tho??? four ppl there, 3 died. also please read the admins response. Put ur gun down and listen

We don't know IC of the names of the individuals who lived. But your guy that's dead inside our compound we have his name and we also have our guys name that's dead with him so it makes sense of a conflict there.

You guys are going on a rampage DMing people saying SOS is after you individually, your a skitzo.

Edited 22 minutes ago by TMH

[Drakarus]

I also wanna mention, neither myself or the other mugger that survived have EVER MET YOU before and that I can confidently say, the third one that died not sure if he knew you but you were not TARGET MUGGED.