James "Noir" McGriff PK Appeal

[Akira]

Name of Character: James "Noir" McGriff

Character ID: 201518

SteamID: STEAM_0:1:439522528

Your Discord ID#: xsfqn

Date of PK: 05.07.2026

Reason for PK: VCWP

Why should you be unPK'd? What server rule or PK rule was violated?: The officer had no valid reason to arrest me in the first place and the cop who shot me wasn't even in uniform. He was wearing plain clothes while acting as a patrol officer.

If possible please provide video evidence or photo evidence if PK does not follow the guidelines:
I was accused of burning a dead body, even though I wasn't the person who did it (This can be verified through the server logs) Because of that false accusation, I attempted to shoot the officer who was trying to arrest me. During the situation, Sergeant Hamida Abdullah shot me with an event weapon (a Musket) while wearing plain clothes and without being in uniform as a patrol Officer.

Afterwards Monaclu switched to his staff character, took the ticket himself, and personally PK'd my character.

I'm not trying to make this into a staff report, but the fact that I was shot by a police character who wasn't in uniform while using an event weapon, and then had the same person switch to their staff character and PK me, doesn't sit right with me. I'll leave it up to the UA team to decide whether that was handled appropriately.

[KingJewMonaclu]

Hi, i'm the person that pked you and the admin who ran the command. I'll address each point individually

1. You were cleaning up the crime scene of a murder. A murder you probably were involved in. I caught you. I have you on recording, both CCTV, and camera when I got on the roof immediately after I left you alone. You may not have *burned* the body, but you 100% picked up the casings, and were involved.

2. "Because of a false accusation, I attempted to shoot a cop" bad choice. You were guilty tho.

3.  This is you, cleaning up casings.

4. I didn't have a uniform on. The policy regarding uniforms is that, if a individual shoots at you not realizing you're a cop, it's not a pk. If you try to arrest someone in a white shirt, and they shoot at you not realizing, your PK might be denied. If you're flagrantly breaking uniform rules to get an easy arrest, to "Suprise taze them", that's another thing that might get your pk denied. In this instance, I was part of an event, and between locations. I was going to get onto a rooftop when I saw you. I had no time to get a uniform on, and I did not try to arrest you as a result. I, instead, alerted another officer who was in uniform and did have tools. He did the arrest. You shot him, as I was running up, and I shot you. This does not invalidate a PK.

5. Yes, staff are too pre-occupied with the event. I do not usually do this, for this exact purpose. I've always disliked taking my own PKs. However, it is actually allowed and completely fine. It's just a preference of mine.

6. Event weapon? It's a gun my guy. We keep those guns. They're real guns. They're ours forever. Also, it's 100% a HANDICAP to try and shoot a guy with a musket (as I didn't have my PD gear on me). Had I missed, as I had the most likely chance to miss and get fucked, you wouldn't be complaining. 

 

[joeeey1]

Brother got that Kentucky Rifle treatment 

[Akira]

Yes, I didn't mean that I wasn't involved in the situation. What I meant was that I wasn't the person who burned the dead body.

You saw me while I was attempting the PK yourself. You told me you were busy and didn't interfere. Instead, you directed another Senior Officer to my location over the radio (it's clear from the clip that you were communicating over the radio). Then while that officer was trying to arrest me you came back and killed me

First you leave an incident that you personally witnessed. Then about five minutes later you return wearing only a white shirt kill me switch to your staff character personally PK my character and even send an event message afterward.

If the UA would like to see it I'm happy to provide my own clip. In the footage you can clearly be heard saying that you weren't going to deal with me before leaving the scene. Yet about five minutes later while not even wearing a proper police uniform you directed a Senior Officer to deal with me then returned yourself and killed me which ultimately led to my PK. Is that really an appropriate or ethical way to handle the situation?

Edited 12 hours ago by Akira

[KingJewMonaclu]

2 hours ago, Akira said:

Yes, I didn't mean that I wasn't involved in the situation. What I meant was that I wasn't the person who burned the dead body.

You saw me while I was attempting the PK yourself. You told me you were busy and didn't interfere. Instead, you directed another Senior Officer to my location over the radio (it's clear from the clip that you were communicating over the radio). Then while that officer was trying to arrest me you came back and killed me

First you leave an incident that you personally witnessed. Then about five minutes later you return wearing only a white shirt kill me switch to your staff character personally PK my character and even send an event message afterward.

If the UA would like to see it I'm happy to provide my own clip. In the footage you can clearly be heard saying that you weren't going to deal with me before leaving the scene. Yet about five minutes later while not even wearing a proper police uniform you directed a Senior Officer to deal with me then returned yourself and killed me which ultimately led to my PK. Is that really an appropriate or ethical way to handle the situation?

yeah i lied to you. i said i wasnt going to do anything, and i got another cop to do something. really i didnt lie, i didnt try to arrest you over it.

ethical? i dont care.

[Akira]

"it's a handicap" isn't a valid excuse when you're an on duty police officer. You had plenty of time to change into your proper uniform, grab your assigned weapon from the PD locker, and investigate. You already knew i had picked up shell casings and that the body had been burned by somebody else. That alone was enough to pursue a warrant especially if CCTV existed.

By that logic any officer could use any weapon they found simply because it was in their possession. That's not how police equipment works. Officers are expected to use department issued weapons, not whatever they happen to have.

The biggest issue is that you were on duty without wearing the proper uniform?? If you wanted to participate in the event you could have gone off duty or switched to another character. Instead you tried to do both at once by acting as a police officer while participating in the event without a proper uniform as a Sergeant.

You were a Sergeant dressed like an off duty officer while searching for a murder suspect giving callouts and using a police cruiser. If you were a detective it would be different but as a Sergeant that isn't realistic and if I'm not mistaken goes against NYPD standards.

From a criminal's perspective, they're looking out for officers in uniform. If your goal was to blend in you could have simply gone off duty or used another character. The only reason the PK happened was because an on duty officer was conducting police activity without being properly dressed.

The only impression this gives me is that you wanted to stay on your police character to participate in the event while still benefiting from spawning with police equipment and body armor. That's only my assumption but that's how it comes across

[Geo_Zeus]

If the knowledge of the RP(Akira messing with the body) was gained incorrectly(Sergeant in plainclothes, participating in an event) I think the PK should also be invalidated since the RP isn't valid.

Seems to me that, since Monaclu was in plain clothes and participating in an event, he was off-duty. The fact that he stumbled upon Akira doing what he was doing doesn't give him the right to actively participate in the scene. You could go as far and argue that reporting the scene was already beyond what the rules allow, but directly participating while off duty is definitely against the rules and should invalidate the whole RP.

[velocity]

You saw him while participating in an event in plain clothes and radioed it in. Another officer responded to the scene. Andy attempted to kill that officer, and you, who were behind him, shot and killed him with a MUSKET. You then switched to your staff character to PK him. Your profile picture doesn't surprise me at all.

I got removed because I set someone from my faction active and sat in a bench for 20 minutes and this dude kills the guy pulls him into a sit to PK himself with no second opinion or other staff, straight up bs. It can be seen that there was 3 admins on their staff characters at the time of this PK.

@Akira Make a staff report and contact commish for fail corruption.

Edited 23 minutes ago by velocity