thinking about it more, PKs, avoiding cops, finding someone active etc, finding people alone to mug blah blah
who knows how long hes been doing this and what hes pulled off with the cheats
seeing this dude is a known mugger i think its safe to suspect there was foul play in his day to day interactions / muggings
as much as i believe in 2nd chances -1 (for now), at least give it time before appealing like previous people whove cheated