Hello sorry for the delay,
So the clip currently no longer exists but we've all seen it and reviewed it. First of all, I'm very sorry to hear the luck you had with them firstly having a BOLO out on a complete different character, that is just very tough luck that they let that person go and that they went for you.
The arresting officer made clear that you were being placed under arrest, since he said it to you whilst you had your back turned and then 2 seconds later started cuffing you. (You also get a different notification on your screen if you are being CUFFED or TIED.)
The officer wasn't arresting you for using your stash but for 'Illegal Open Carry." The best thing you can do if you actually were being fail-mugged is by not handling it yourself in-character, since then you'll make it harder for your actions to be voided.
We do believe you had intentions to start a violent confrontation with the police and therefore you were killed. If you want to transport firearms, gunbags were added for a reason so it's less risky to get caught whilst transporting.
Your appeal has been reviewed and denied.
We have determined this PK to be reasonable and/or justified.
You may not re-appeal this PK.