The reason this appeal took so long is because when metagame is an excuse to something, its looked into deeply. The outcome of that, is that we found no evidence of metagaming, infact, we actually saw more proof to justify no metagame happening, than proof that they were metagaming.
There was a 911 call, false or not, thats an in character issue. The person also who made the call, had no mutual factions with the person being kidnapped, and the call was made right infront of your door.
Now for the cops raiding the place, they saw the 911 call and were already in the area, hence why they came in fast and hard. You should not of shot at the cops if you wanted a chance to not be pked on the spot. With all of that information, the only foul play here that I could find is the basis for the 911 call. The raid by NYPD was also an IC issue, because 911 calls are not probably cause to kick a door down. The tying sound is also very loud, and very easily can be heard through the walls.
Your appeal has been reviewed and denied.
We have determined this PK to be reasonable and/or justified.
You may not re-appeal this PK.