"There was 3 people in the call total, me, the staff member, and a different member that wasn't related. " "Neither one of them were involved in the mug, just me."
You can hear someone in the discord tell Sauerkraut that he had a gun on him. If they were involved with the mugging, then it would be fine, but this is a discussion about metagaming. Them not being involved directly doesn't help anything.
Metagame = Using Out of Character information In-Character -- From the rules.
Also I have to ask, is it normal for staff to accept audioless cut down PK clips or is it just because this one is your friend?