Hi Calink,
While I can't speak for the notes and rule breaks and understand your logic there I can speak to these.
This person has been accepted into the 14k and was a valued member before they were unfortunately pked. Yes they did get into some trouble with cops quite a bit, but they did do the RP we required and never brought the trouble to the organization. Their name was a valid RP name and their new character which was at the time "Maria Lee" was going to be a good citizen and rejoin the 14k after the cooldown. I had personally spoken to them about them being more law abiding and not getting arrested on their new char going forward. They agreed and were even taking the bar exam.
Overall I understand your side and can see your perspective. I just wanted to answer to these two points as I did slightly disagree with them.
Thanks!