Marcus Smart

[David Mason]

Name of Character: Marcus Smart 

Character ID: idk how to get it if im dead

SteamID: davidmason

Your Discord ID#:728708863653576774

Date of PK:9/29/2026

Reason for PK: in a situation where people point guns at me i was looking at them to talk to them and then thy told me to face the wall so i move to the wall and they kill me the staff said i "tried to jump off" but 1: why would i do that no benefit 2: i feel like there is a whole rooftop to jump off of and i walk towards the only wall that i could not so i could face and be up against the wall? also good point made by guy at the end i was never told to not move.

Why should you be unPK'd? What server rule or PK rule was violated?: i was not told to not move and was following orders to my best ability 

If possible please provide video evidence or photo evidence if PK does not follow the guidelines: https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/nD3eQtNUwRaX5kEgQ?invite=cr-MSwzV2YsMTg2MDA0NTUw

[Mickey Lunestra]

You were told not to look at us, you kept looking at us, we told you to face the very large wall that is not facing us.

you decide to run towards a exit that is in my direction so I shoot you, we can also mention you and your friend who kept breaking NLR to come back and record people in little italy

and you are cutting out discord audio with him

[Built Different]

Hello! one of the ladies who was involved in your mugging, You were mugged because you and a friend were actively taking photos of people with guns out while threatening to go to detectives and namedropping them entirely in front of ATM CCTV. We came after you because you had a photo of myself with a class 3 and a friend with a class 4 on our backs so we had no choice but to mug you for your cameras. You were told to face the wall and proceeded to walk towards the dropdown to the dumpster instead of just looking away from us like instructed, Apologies but it's really shitty to hop on a civ char and try to ruin people's characters 

[Wickers]

Hello, I was the Staff Administrator who deemed this character kill was valid simply due to the reasons I will state below.

-You were given orders to stop moving and look at a certain wall, while you decided to keep moving and make eye contact while told not do so.

-You then started walking into the wall that was close to the edge so you can jump off....

-You also had no fear for your life whatsoever so this makes in my opinion a valid PK.


Good luck with your appeal!

[David Mason]

19 hours ago, Mickey Lunestra said:

You were told not to look at us, you kept looking at us, we told you to face the very large wall that is not facing us.

you decide to run towards a exit that is in my direction so I shoot you, we can also mention you and your friend who kept breaking NLR to come back and record people in little italy

and you are cutting out discord audio with him

after the guy i was looking at said "dont look at me" then i looked away from him then they said "look away from us" and i did. followed instructions as they were given. 2 what exit the 40 foot drop? telling me to face the wall and i go and face the wall and not the other building with the edge. if i wanted to jump as several of you have said i would have from RIGHT INFRONT OF ME instead of going to the wall. and what benefit would killing myself while pk active give me like you guys can see the clip i went to the wall and stood there for half a sec before getting aired out.  and as the discord audio shit i did not mute shit and what relevance to the validity of the pk does that have?? 

[David Mason]

14 hours ago, Built Different said:

Hello! one of the ladies who was involved in your mugging, You were mugged because you and a friend were actively taking photos of people with guns out while threatening to go to detectives and namedropping them entirely in front of ATM CCTV. We came after you because you had a photo of myself with a class 3 and a friend with a class 4 on our backs so we had no choice but to mug you for your cameras. You were told to face the wall and proceeded to walk towards the dropdown to the dumpster instead of just looking away from us like instructed, Apologies but it's really shitty to hop on a civ char and try to ruin people's characters 

first half of this is just why u guys mugged me which i never refuted. and the "You were told to face the wall and proceeded to walk towards the dropdown to the dumpster instead" if you look at my clip you can see i did not do that and walked towards the only actual wall that is not a ledge with a drop. legitimately went the only direction i could stand against.

[David Mason]

6 hours ago, Wickers said:

Hello, I was the Staff Administrator who deemed this character kill was valid simply due to the reasons I will state below.

-You were given orders to stop moving and look at a certain wall, while you decided to keep moving and make eye contact while told not do so.

-You then started walking into the wall that was close to the edge so you can jump off....

-You also had no fear for your life whatsoever so this makes in my opinion a valid PK.


Good luck with your appeal!

-You were given orders to stop moving and look at a certain wall, while you decided to keep moving and make eye contact while told not do so.

they never said once to not move at all and they never specified what wall. so i went to the only actual wall. i dont know why we are saying stuff that did not happen when there is a video of everything that occurred and was said.

-You then started walking into the wall that was close to the edge so you can jump off....
walked towards the only wall i could not jump off of if i wanted to jump i would have. and what benefit would that do for me. dying?

-You also had no fear for your life whatsoever so this makes in my opinion a valid PK.

im sorry my voice was not filled with absolute terror and fear ill do better next time. but fr i did what i would think most people would do and try and follow instructions to the best ability. i had no feasible weapon and no intent to resist so i had nothing to worry about. i dont care about what items i had on me and as long as i complied i would not die. so that was what i was trying to do comply.

[Pendred]

14 hours ago, Built Different said:

Hello! one of the ladies who was involved in your mugging, You were mugged because you and a friend were actively taking photos of people with guns out while threatening to go to detectives and namedropping them entirely in front of ATM CCTV. We came after you because you had a photo of myself with a class 3 and a friend with a class 4 on our backs so we had no choice but to mug you for your cameras. You were told to face the wall and proceeded to walk towards the dropdown to the dumpster instead of just looking away from us like instructed, Apologies but it's really shitty to hop on a civ char and try to ruin people's characters 

you're a nigga bro relax

[Built Different]

11 minutes ago, Pendred said:

you're a nigga bro relax

Keeping it in character smh

[JJ_]

While the demands given by the muggers are not particularly clearest, I believe they were still clear enough for someone to reasonably understand what was being asked of them. Given that you are a long time player with a decent amount of playtime, I find it unlikely that you genuinely did not know how to put your hands up. Instead of immediately complying, you repeatedly asked, “what key, what key".

Additionally, you walked directly toward the only ledge where you would have had a reasonable chance of surviving the fall. Given the circumstances, I find this telling and believe it is reasonable to see your actions as an attempt to find a way out rather than simply complying with the demands.

Edited 17 minutes ago by JJ_

[JJ_]

Your appeal has been reviewed and denied.

We have determined this PK to be reasonable and/or justified.

You may not re-appeal this PK.