Matthew Stiner PK appeal

[Matthew Stiner]

PK Appeal Format
Below is the format that you must followed when making a PK appeal, you must copy all sections and fill them out in detail.

Rules:
You may only make one appeal per PK, if you are denied you will be unable to appeal for that character again.

You must appeal within one week of your character being PK'd, appeals posted after this time will be automatically denied.

You may only comment on an appeal if you were DIRECTLY involved with the situation leading up to the PK. Replies that are not relevant to the situation will result in a forum warning and/or ban.

You must follow the provided template for the appeal, failure to do so will result in an instant denial.


Name of Character: Matthew Stiner 

Character ID: 10894 (if this is wrong lemme know)

SteamID: 76561198043292555

Your Discord ID#: mxcrazy98

Date of PK: September 8th 2025

Reason for PK: Was told it was for leaving a faction 

Why should you be unPK'd? What server rule or PK rule was violated?: I was never in the faction as a real member. I was asked by people in Corsican mob if i wanted to be the doctor for people on the street. Essentially being the local medic. I never asked for any kind of join status, i never paid dues, and i never did any tasks other than medical aid to people when i was on the server. To be PKd because i joined Rockefeller seems absurd since i was still more than happy to do any medical stuff anyone needed, that was my only service or participation. I never did any hits, swore any oaths, did any missions, or any tasks for anyone other than talk about medicine in game and IRL. 

I should also note, i never asked an admin for the faction change, someone else asked and did that for me. 

If being a family doctor is enough to count as a char PK then id have never said anything to them.  Ive done lots for other people in the exact same capacity but because someone said got the admin to give me perms for the door i count towards a PK? I dont know it seems a little steep to me. I had no idea this was the reality since ive never been in a faction other than USC, Public defenders office, Marshals and NYPD. Non of those had any harsh terms for leaving or changing jobs at all. 

All I'm asking for is some curtsey about me not knowing that this was a one and done only thing i could do was be in X. I was never told if i left or changed jobs i could be PKd. No one ever told me any rules about the faction, no one ever told me we had anything like an SOP or guidelines. As far as i was concerned, i was a doctor for people in that family and next door. 

If possible please provide video evidence or photo evidence if PK does not follow the guidelines:

Edited 7 hours ago by Matthew Stiner
edit to 1st paragraph

[Mmmm_Cookies]

Hey man, orders were put on you for leaving the faction, while normally this could be considered okay for us, you had done illegal activities and had knowledge that we couldn't leave you with. Hope this helps, you also get a warning when joining of the possible repercussions. 

[Matthew Stiner]

I never did anything illegal with them! I had no knowledge of anything going on and no one ever invited me to any criminal acts. 

Im gonna say thins again, I DID NOT ASK FOR THE FACTION JOIN! I said id be happy to be your family doctor and 5 mins later wasnt a citizen of NYC. 

Edited 7 hours ago by Matthew Stiner
Edit to composition

[yummekoo]

Hi I was the admin that approved of your Pk! The reason why you were PKed was because you left the faction and you knew too much! You also hadn't asked for permission to leave the faction which was the main cause of why they PKed you. I checked logs and while yes you might've just been a doctor and talked about medicine you had done something illegal for them. (Which led to the acceptance of your PK.) 

[Matthew Stiner]

What did i do thats illegal???? 

 

[yummekoo]

4 minutes ago, Matthew Stiner said:

What did i do thats illegal???? 

 

drug

[Matthew Stiner]

I never sold any drugs, was involved in drug trade, or knew of anyone with drugs at any point. 

the only thing ive ever sold was oil. Privately or to rockerfeller. Thats it 

Edited 7 hours ago by Matthew Stiner

[JJ_]

Hello, there are two key points I’d like to address regarding your appeal.

First, while you stated that you did not sell drugs or engage in any illegal activity, the logs show that you did, in fact, order a shipment of meth during your time in the Corsican Mob. Generally, PK's are not accepted if a person had no involvement or awareness of illegal activities within the faction they were part of. In this case, it’s clear that you were aware and directly participated by ordering that shipment.

Second, you mentioned that you didn’t exactly ask to join this faction. However, joining requires a confirmation pop-up on your screen, where you are given the option to accept or decline. This means you chose to join the faction voluntarily.

[JJ_]

Your appeal has been reviewed and denied.

We have determined this PK to be reasonable and/or justified.

You may not re-appeal this PK.