Item transfer PK apeal

[HouseFire]

Name of Character: Dennis "Cent" Bergulio

SteamID: 76561199188285153

Your Discord ID#: iwantsleep1

Date of PK: March 8th 2025

Reason for PK: Item transfer middleman

Why should you be unPK'd? What server rule or PK rule was violated?: I don't feel that this is really fair as the whole thing had been a mistake. When the transfer happened I had been acting as a model for SlugTrail, but while modeling I had forgotten to give one item back to the correct character (he had another character in which he wanted to sell some items on) so when I gave it back to him I gave it back to the wrong character with neither one of us noticing. You can see in the logs that he is dropping a number of items in which I pick up, equip, he takes a picture, I unequip, and then drop, with some of the items being owned by his other character. I don't have any notes or past offenses and I would not have done this knowingly. It was certainly an accident on my end and I believe it was also an accident on SlugTrails part as it's understandable how he could've gone one out of the probably 30-40+ clothing items we were messing with. No PK rule was violated I just believe a PK is unfair as the rule break was accidental, a ban I believe is justifiable as I did break the rules even if not intentional but I feel a PK isn't for the same reason.

If possible please provide video evidence or photo evidence if PK does not follow the guidelines: I do not

[xDutchCat]

Hello

Banning and PKing administrator here,

The reason why I pkd you and SlugTrail was with the reason of an itemtransfer of a "Flamingo's Chain (Rose Gold)".

Character Magus Ingrid(Slugtrail) dropped the chain on that character and gave it to you. He got back on his "Giano Bergulio" character and you gave that same chain to him in 3 minutes. (A photoshoot does not take 6 days on the logs, he gave the item to Thomas on the 1st of January and went back to him almost instant) I saw clear intent in the evidence provided by the logs. You were mature enough to understand when I elaborated to you you transferred with SlugTrail and he also lied about his namechange. I mean I couldve let you off with just a ban for being a middleman but honestly I don't know

Item Transfer is Item Transfer, no matter if it happend ≈ 3 months ago, it is still a rule break.

 

Edited yesterday at 04:40 AM by xDutchCat

[Sneak]

Ima be real, it’s a Flamingo chain, just a ban is good enough. It isn’t like he sent over like 50 things like some of these other dudes.

[HouseFire]

"You were mature enough to understand when I elaborated to you" In the sit I was "mature" and didn't fight at all since I had no idea what had really happened and couldn't explain (as the offense was 2 months prior.) But afterwards I had spoken to SlugTrail and we were able to figure out what had happened (as he has pictures from the photoshoot). "you gave that same chain to him in 3 minutes." I had forgotten to drop him the chain (I believe I also forgot to drop two suit pants, I also believe this is the cause of the transfer) as we were taking pictures of a number of items. "A photoshoot does not take 6 days on the logs, he gave the item to Thomas on the 1st of January and went back and forth quite a bit" This was because SlugTrail was unaware of the transfer at the time and was redoing the pictures for his catalog.

[James]

This punishment was too harsh for what happened; the ban was sufficient, so I will be overturning this.

Your appeal has been reviewed and accepted.

Your character has been reinstated and can be used again.